REVIEW AND OPPONENT`S REVIEW IN THE SYSTEM OF SCIENTIFIC AND LITERARY-CRITICAL GENRES (part 2)

Authors

Keywords:

review, opponent’s review, genre, literary and artistic criticism, scientific discourse

Abstract

The article analyzes the views of contemporary researchers on the essence of the concepts “criticism”, “literary criticism” and “art criticism”. It is noted that these concepts should be considered synonymous, since they all indicate the ability to analyze and evaluate artistic works. The authors of this research offer their own interpretation of the term “literary and artistic criticism”, which is understood as a scientific or professional interpretation of an artistic (literary) work in the context of ideological and aesthetic guidelines of the time, socio-political factors and professional skills of the interpreter. It was determined that in the contemporary literary and critical discourse, a review is understood as one of the most widespread genres in this field, the purpose of which is the analysis and evaluation of an artistic, artistic, journalistic, scientific work in the context of historical, social and political realities, as well as consideration of the corpus violated in the work problems. It was determined that the similarity of literary and critical review and opponent’s review is caused by common structural components, a common goal, the influence of the ideological and aesthetic paradigm of a certain period (the tendency to dominate modification forms in our time) and the desire to respond to the requests of the contemporary audience.

References

Academic writing: teaching. manual / arrangement Revutska S., Zinchenko V. (2019). Kryvyi Rih. 130 p.

Bagan O. (2009). Temptations and pitfalls of literary criticism. https://litakcent.online/2009/06/15/spokusy-i-pastky-literaturnoji-krytyky/

Balatska O. (2019). On the problem of definition of the concept “scientific criticism”. Scientific Bulletin of the International Humanitarian University. Series: Philology. No. 42. Volume 2. P. 24-27.

Barchan O. (2021). Work program of the academic discipline «Theory and Practice of Print Journalism».URL: https://www.uzhnu.edu.ua/uk/infocentre/get/37876

Bruhovetskyi S. (1984). Zanr literaturno-hudozn’oi krytyky. Ukrains’ka literaturna entsyklopedia. URL: https://1668.slovaronline.com/

Dmytrovsky Z. (2021). Analytical journalism. URL: https://journ.lnu.edu.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/lektsii-z-TMZHT-dots.-Dmytrovs-koho-Z.-YE.-.rtf

Dupak O. (2008). A literaty review in Ukrainian printing massmedia: featur es of transformation of genre. Scientific notes of the Tavri National University named after V.I.Vernadskyi. Series “Philology. Social communication”. Volume 21 (60). No. 1. P. 50-55.

Haramurza D. (2022). The mass media factor of literary criticism of Ukraine (1995-2015): thesis... Doctor of Philosophy. Sumy. 209 p.

Halych O., Nazarets V., Vasiliev E. (2006). Theory of literature: 3rd edition. Kyiv. 488 p.

Hrom’ak R. (1999). Istoria ukrains’koi literaturnoi krutyky (vid pochatkiv do kintsia 19 stolittia): [posib. dlia stud. humanitar. f-tiv vyshch. navch. zakl.]. Т: Pidruchnyky & posibnyky. 224 p.

Каchkhan V. (1999). Іryna Vilde: Narys zyttia I tvorchosti. Кyiv: Dnipro. 153 p.

Kornilov E. (2017). Mass communications at the turn of the millennium: monograph / 2nd ed., pp. URL: https://rucont.ru/efd/244358/

Korotkyi tlumachnyi slovnyk ukrains’koi movy. (1978). URL: https://shron1.chtyvo.org.ua/Humetska_LL/Korotkyi_tlumachnyi_slovnyk_ukrainskoi_movy.pdf?

Kravets O. (2021). Work program of the study discipline “History of Slavic Criticism”. https://philology.lnu.edu.ua/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/rpistor.slov.liter.krytyky.pdf.

Kuzmenko K. (2008). Tone and measure of criticism in a critical article (on the example of modern Ukrainian reviews). Publisher: Institute of Journalism. P. 18-26. URL: http://journlib.univ.kiev.ua/index.php/index.php?act=article&article=2294

Literuturoznavcha entsyklopedia: U dvoch tomah. Т. 1. / Аvt.-uklad. Yu. Коvaliv. (2007). Кyiv: VTs «Аkademia». 608 с.

Literuturoznavchyi slovnyk-dovidnyk / Za red. R. Т. Hrom’aka, Yu. І. Коvalivа, V. І. Теremka (2007). Кyiv: VTs «Аkademia». 752 p.

Law of Ukraine “On Higher Education”. (2019). URL: https://ips.ligazakon.net/document/view/t141556?an=1626&ed=2019_01_01

Mass media in terms and definitions: Short dictionary-reference / comp. Y. V. Bondar (2005). Kyiv: MAUP. 224 p.

Мyhailyn І. (2002). Osnovy zyrnalistyky. Kyiv: TSUL. 284 p.

National doctrine of education development of Ukraine (2013). URL: https://repository.ldufk.edu.ua/bitstream/34606048/3438/1/natsionalna%20doktryna.pdf

National Qualifications Framework (2019-2021). URL: https://mon.gov.ua/tag/natsionalna-ramka-kvalifikatsiy

National strategy for the development of education in Ukraine for the period until 2021. (2013). URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/344/2013#Text

Panieva Yu., Zvyniatkovskyi V. (2019). To the definition of the concept of “literary criticism”. URL: https://dspace.uzhnu.edu.ua/jspui/bitstream/lib/

Poddubniak V. (2005). Dictionary of journalist and publisher. Kherson: KhMD. 120 p.

Podlypska A. (2019). Art criticism and art history in modern conditions. Bulletin of the National Academy of Managers of Culture and Arts. No. 1. P. 379-383.

Podolyan M. (1998). Journalism as a system of genres. Kyiv: Kyiv University, Institute of Journalism, Free Press Center. 48 p.

Ryzak L. (2008). Yevrointegratsia vishchoi osvity Ukrainy: aksiologichnyi vymir. Visnyk Lvivskogo universytetu. Vyp. 11. P. 27-37. URL: http://archive.nbuv.gov.ua/portal/natural/vlnu/ philos/2008_11/3.pdf

Riabchuk М. (2002). Why can’t I be a critic. Criticism. No. 12. URL: https://krytyka.com/ua/articles/chomu-ya-mozhu-ne-buty-krytykom

Serazym К. (2008). Тextoznavstvo: pidruchnyk. Kyiv: «Кyivskyi universytet». 527 с.

Strategy for the development of higher education in Ukraine for 2022-2032. (2022). URL: https://mon.gov.ua/osvita-2/vishcha-osvita-ta-osvita-doroslikh/strategiya-rozvitku-vishchoi-osviti-v-ukraini-na-2022-2032-roki

Sustainable development strategy “Ukraine – 2020”. (2015). URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/5/2015#Text

Tertychny O. (2010). Analytical journalism: Education. guide for

university students. 352 p.

The program of the academic discipline “Literary and artistic criticism in mass media”. (2022). URL: https://pg.cabinet.sumdu.edu.ua/key=S8TpFOIbqhLbOkyX22djJHerXebedgsX2AtddTskMZh4qRsB0wea#2043499

Zdrovega V. (2004a). About journalism and journalists: articles, essays, speeches, dialogues. Lviv: Ivan Franko LNU Publishing Center. 133 p.

Zdrovega V. (2004b). Theory and methodology of journalistic creativity. 2nd edition Lviv, 2004. URL: http://194.44.152.155/elib/local/sk682275.pdf.

Published

2024-07-07

How to Cite

Ishchenko, O., & Oropaі A. (2024). REVIEW AND OPPONENT`S REVIEW IN THE SYSTEM OF SCIENTIFIC AND LITERARY-CRITICAL GENRES (part 2). Philological Treatises, 16(1), 39–49. Retrieved from https://tractatus.sumdu.edu.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/1155